You are here: Is a ground source heat pump right for my home?

What factors to consider before you buy

As energy efficiency and sustainability are becoming increasingly important, many homeowners are considering alternative heating solutions to boilers. Among the most eco-friendly options available is the ground source heat pump (GSHP). But a GSHP isn’t right for every property. Among the key factors to consider are your site’s suitability, if it’s for a new building or a retrofit and your budget.

With thanks to Jack Preston, mechanical engineer form RHB, for his help with this article.

What is a ground source heat pump?

A ground source heat pump is a renewable energy system that harnesses the natural heat stored in the ground to heat your home and, in some cases, provide hot water. It works by circulating a mixture of water and antifreeze through a network of pipes, known as a ground loop, buried in the garden. This mixture absorbs heat from the ground, which is then concentrated by the heat pump and used to warm your home via radiators or underfloor heating.

The ground is heated by the sun – so these heat pumps are making use of solar energy. In this sense GSHPs are renewable but electricity is still required to run the pump. Bear in mind that heat pumps can also supply cooling which is becoming more important as climate change continues to accelerate. Experts predict more heatwaves for the UK in future.

What make a site suitable for a heat pump?

Before installing a GSHP, it’s essential for a specialist to assess whether your property is suitable. Several factors influence the feasibility and efficiency of a GSHP.

Available space

GSHPs require space for the installation of the ground loop. There are two main types of loop systems: horizontal and vertical. Horizonal loops are laid in trenches about 1.5 metres below ground level, requiring a large area of land. Vertical loops, meanwhile, are drilled into the ground making them more suitable for properties with limited space. The downside is this costs more  and requires a drilling rig.

So, how much land is needed for an average 8kW GSHP? Jack says: “It would depend on whether a ground array or borehole arrangement is installed. On average the surface area of land required is approximately 2.5 times the square meterage of the house or in damp cohesive soil, you may expect 50m2 of ground per kW, so your 8kW unit would need 4002 of ground. Typically, 75m to 100m deep boreholes provide 3-5 kW of extractable heat. Therefore, for an 8kW unit,you may require two to three boreholes.” These figures are very much rule of thumb, adds Preston, and a specialist would need to assess your individual property and advise.

Soil and ground conditions

The type of soil and ground conditions in your garden also affect the efficiency of a GSHP. Moist, clay-rich soils conduct heat better than dry, sandy soils. Depending on your ground conditions, you may need a longer or more expensive ground loop to achieve the same efficiency. Hard rocky ground may be difficult to drill while a steeply sloping site will present other problems. A flat area of land is preferable to ease installation and ensure all pipework is laid at the same level, says Jack. Whether the site is shaded or exposed to bright sunshine shouldn’t matter due to the depth at which the pipework is installed, he adds.

Existing landscaping

If your garden already has mature trees or a beautiful lawn and flowerbeds, installing a horizontal loop system may cause significant disruption. In such cases, a vertical loop might be a better option, though it comes at a higher cost.

Planning rules

Planning permission is generally not required for GSHP installation, but there are exceptions. If your property is listed or located in a conservation area, check with your local council before going ahead with the installation.

New build vs existing building: does it matter?

Whether you’re building a new home or retrofitting an existing property, a GSHP can be a viable option, but it will make a difference.

New build

Heat pumps work best in highly insulated, airtight newly built properties. Modern homes are automatically constructed to higher standards of energy efficiency, thanks to updated Building Regulations. Good insulation minimises heat loss, allowing the pump to work more efficiently and keep your home comfortable with less energy. Plus, underfloor heating is often a feature of modern homes. This is ideal for getting the best performance from a heat pump. 

Existing properties

Older buildings tend to be less airtight and leak more heat. If your home can’t be insulated to modern standards, it may require the higher temperatures delivered by a boiler rather than a heat pump. If you retrofit a GSHP in an existing, older building “a much larger ground array or number of boreholes would be required to offset these (heat) losses, which can be incredibly expensive,” explains Jack.

How well do ground source heat pumps perform?

GSHPs are incredibly efficient when it comes to home heating. Unlike air source heat pumps, which draw heat from the air, GSHPs tap into the relatively constant temperatures found below ground, providing reliable performance year-round. In winter when outside temperatures often fall to just below zero and space heating is needed, the ground remains a steady 10-12C. “The efficiency of a GSHP remains relatively stable throughout the year due to the constant ground temperature, minimising spikes in electricity usage. Whereas the efficiency of an ASHP can vary across the season, dependent on the outdoor air temperatures,” explains Jack.

It's important to understand how the efficiency of a heat pump is measured to compare it to other forms of heating. A ratio, known as a Coefficient of Performance (COP), measures the amount of heat produced compared to the electricity used. Typically, GSHPs boast a COP of three, meaning three units of heat energy are produced for each unit of electricity consumed. Some heat pumps can reach a COP of four, suppliers claim. This makes them four times more efficient than the best condensing gas boilers.

Several factors influence a heat pump’s performance. The length and type of ground loop (vertical or horizontal) plays a crucial role. Proper installation is essential; a well sized system tailored to your home’s heating needs helps optimal performance. Performance is also dependent on the amount of hot water delivered by a GSHP. The heat pump works less efficiently when required to heat water to the higher temperature required for taps and showers.

Running costs and carbon emissions

Electricity costs are nearly four times as much as gas per kWh. This means GSHPs may be slightly more expensive to run than modern gas boilers. However, GSHPs tend to have lower running costs compared to air source heat pumps and electric systems in general, including storage heaters. According to Greenmatch, annual GSHP running costs range from £650 to £1,050 on average (prices correct August, 2024). Pairing solar panels with a heat pump will create a more cost-effective and sustainable heating and cooling system for year-round comfort because it it will significantly reduce reliance on electricity from the National Grid.

The initial installation costs of GSHPs are high – from £17,000 to £35,000 -depending on the system size and complexity. But these costs can be partly offset by government grants. The Boiler Upgrade Scheme (BUS) offers £7,500 to help cover the installation costs of renewable heating systems, including GSHPs. BUS covers owner-occupied homes in England and Wales. Self-build properties are also eligible for this grant. For existing properties, homeowners will need an Energy Performance Certificate (EPC) with no outstanding recommendations for loft or cavity wall insulation.

In terms of carbon emissions, GSHPs are a low-carbon, eco-friendly choice. They extract warmth from the ground by using buried pipework rather than producing it by burning fossil fuels. Although they require electricity to operate, they produce more heat energy than they consume, so they can significantly reduce the carbon footprint of your home. If paired with a renewable electricity supply, such as solar panels or a green energy tariff, the carbon emissions can be reduced even further.

A ground source heat pump can be an excellent investment for your home, offering low running costs, high efficiency and significant reductions in carbon emissions. For those in new builds or planning extensive renovations, integrating a GSHP can offer benefits for years to come. For existing homes, especially older ones, additional insulation work may be needed to maximise the benefits of this renewable technology. Ultimately, whether this type of heat pump is suitable for your home will depend on the size of your property and bank balance.

If you are considering extending or altering your home, you may find some of these services useful: