You are here: How has the Party wall Act changed?
This paper was originally presented at a CPD Conferences Course in April 2024. A recording of this talk can also be found on the CPD Conferences Website.
1 Cover slide
2 History – Where the Act came from - in the 1st century we find our first mention of party walls when Vituvius set down rules for the construction of separating walls between owners.
The Romans also had a strange ritual for meeting at the rear corner of the garden once a year to celebrate neighbourliness, I do wonder if one or more owners got left out where there were odd numbers of properties.
Anyway the first real legislation in the UK dates back to 1667 following the great fire of London In the previous year, this was followed by a succession of local acts including the London building Acts amendment Act 1939 part VI, and the act as we see it today is based on that London legislation and of course being London centric it fails sometime to deal with issues outside of the London such as areas where there are granite sub soils which may form the foundation of a building
3 What Garden feature are you - – Its important when dealing with party wall matters to be familiar with other issues that may arise that are outside of your remit, but on occasion too much knowledge can be damaging if it’s not channelled in the right direction, it’s quite possible that you can overload a lay person, lose sight of your own appointment and worse of all make awards for matters that are not within your jurisdiction. Useful tools for a neighbourly matters surveyor might be a limited or greater knowledge of Rights to light, Cranes and Scaffold licence requirements and possibly boundaries, but not it’s not always helpful so remember limit your advice to within the Act
4 The question of intra vires -what is intra vires ?
This is a slight crib from the now retired Judge Baileys talk to another organisation, but do I agree ? –
Let’s start with should party wall surveyors limit their role to determining only matters in dispute ? –
The judge said Party wall surveyors’ should be intra vires, that is within the scope of the surveyor’s powers; they should act with impartially, with a lack of bias (not inconsistent with ensuring that the appointing owner’s interests are protected); and so as to ensure that each owner, usually through that owner’s appointed surveyor, has the opportunity to put forward for consideration any matter relevant to the making of the award; - so as to ensure that both owners’ cases are given proper consideration;
On that note I do have some concerns as to how much we consider the views of the owners and don’t necessarily agree with judge Baily’s statement and I would urge caution as quite often this can open up all kinds of other matters that are not Act related. One really has to understand the nature of the concerns and at this point your advice on what you can and can’t do is essential
And thoroughly, so as to ensure that all necessary investigations are carried out before making an award and that the award is made having regard to all the material obtained.
So, to answer the question – should you determine only matters in dispute - ? YES
5 Should you be determining the position of the boundary? – no
Simply put it is not a matter for the surveyors under the Act, certainly in all normal circumstances when we are considering a normal party wall we probably don’t need to ascertain where the boundary is as its obvious, but that isn’t always the case and it’s important to recognise that it isn’t the role of the party wall surveyor to ‘determine’ the boundary. We simply take the assertions of the building owner and use the information they have provided.
There is of course nothing to stop you taking a separate appointment to deal with the position of the boundary, but expertise is required. I personally use or recommend a land surveyor who has all the necessary equipment and expertise where boundaries are difficult to identify.
I do of course point out to owners where I feel they may have the boundary wrong and I ask them to refer back to the architect or engineer for clarification. I also have in my terms and conditions that I do not determine boundaries as in the event of a dispute as to the position of the award may be challenged and I suspect if you have made a unilateral assessment its possible you might find yourself at risk.
Can I also suggest that you consider using the RICS neighbourly matters services form which is a bit basic but does allow you to tick or not tick various services when offering a neighbourly matters service thus avoiding any confusion over what you will or will not be doing?
6 Intra vires - What have the courts said
So, what have the courts said about being within the Act or ‘ Intra Vires’ ?
Below are a number of cases that show where surveyors have got it wrong, there are some very useful hints as to appropriate actions here, but it is important to note that a surveyors interpretation of the Act may not be what the courts think, some of these cases are of course unchallenged and non-binding, and there are a few where I have to say the surveyors where probably doing the right thing but the Act didn’t allow it so they should perhaps have dealt with it in a different manner. The following are the cases I refer to and I will expand on this in the lecture – (the following paper contains only a short summary of the main points only)
Gray v elite town Management – 2015 – in this case the 3rd surveyor unlawfully allowed special foundations – (if you don’t know what that is I will explain shortly)
Shah v Power and Kyson (2020-22) - No notice no Act (a large number of cases ultimately landing in the court of appeal and decided
May and crown – The question was whether the third surveyor was outside of his jurisdiction, was he competent having not been to site ? The case also highlights that damages must be related to the Act / notified works
Evans v Paterson - The surveyors didn’t allow owners the chance to dispute a claim for damages and made an award, it was appealed on the basis that the owners were not in dispute
K Group – rather a messy one but an award cited the wrong party, it was 11 years late, and an exparte award – well worth a read but simply out a example of terrible management.
Ash Trimnel – this award Tried to deal with a common law issue for access where none was provided under the Act – I will elaborate in the talk
Rega v mills – two surveyors awarded but didn’t have jurisdiction it should have been the third surveyor (isle of wight)
Lion homes – need clear evidence of a dispute – no dispute had arisen.
7 - Graduates and the role of the appointed surveyor
It’s important to note that you can be at risk of being pulled in as an expert in litigation, and even the most obscure notice just for flashing can lead to a massive job. (I will give an example later in the talk / presentation).
8 Graduates and the role of the appointed surveyor - This is what the RICS public guide says – and this is where I get on my high horse as I am the author of the guidance.
Yes, I am aware that the guide is an RICS guide and therefore aimed at promoting its own members, to be clear I have no issue with other professional bodies also promoting the use of seasoned professionals, however, I do feel its wholly inappropriate for graduates, non-qualified or trainees surveyors to administer the Act.
I believe that the Act requires someone who has an understanding of construction to be the administrator and despite the Act not stating what a surveyor is I think it should be obvious, we really need to public to understand that a two-day course is not what makes a professional surveyor and there should be some acknowledgement of the proper use of the term surveyor. To that end I am trying to persuade the RICS to bring forth an accreditation scheme to set a bar of excellence.
I have no issue with RICS members in all categories, Assoc members included going for the accreditation and also members of other professional bodies and as long as they pass the bar so that we can show the public who is and who isn’t competent !
9 photo – this is an example of a job I’m involved with where the initial notice was simply for cutting away a flashing ! and you can see now why a graduate should not be the named surveyor !
10 – photo and 11 – photo – and this is what happens when it all goes wrong possibly because a Graduate is the name surveyor ?! (although this particular photo is Possibly not part wall related, but nevertheless it’s an example of what might be a party wall consequence).
12 What’s changed? What have the courts said?
The Act has not changed since its introduction save for a small amend to section 15 to deal with electronic communications but the way we administer certain sections has and that is primarily because of the interpretations the courts have given to certain definitions and phrases.
First of all, it’s worth mentioning that the RICS guidance was edited and will be edited again the last time it was because of a justified criticism of the draft award which came about in the case of lea valley v Derbyshire, where although the RICS template is purely a guide it failed to recognise that making good is only relevant to certain section of the Act not all and in particular not section 6.
As well as amends to that particular clause the new RICS draft award allows for insertion in the introduction of matters that are not part of the award or outside of the jurisdiction of the surveyors but on which the surveyors may have relied in making their award. It may be for instance that the surveyors are aware of an access licence thus avoiding the need to award access for say a minor flashing detail or that there is a direct agreement on the quantum for security or 11 (11) payments, again something that the surveyors may consider relevant to the dispute but not a matter for the award as it has been resolved by direct communication between the owners.
We are looking at amending the draft award later this year and there were some helpful suggestions by the Pyraumus and thisbe Society who adopted the RICS standard but tweaked it little so watch this space .
As I mentioned the case, I should also point out that in the lea valley case the question of diminution vs remedial costs was brought up, but sadly this remains undecided. I will be happy to explore this in more detail in the Qand A section if required.
For now, I'm going to discuss the top three cases (on the slide) to show how case law has changed the way we administer the Act but other worthy mentions are listed and I will let you review those for yourselves but just for a quick overview -
Ormiston Kilsby v Fattahi (2019) – is a case that links nicely with the no notice no Act scenario and should be read to put off the developer simply thinking the act doesn’t apply and is a case that deals quite adequately with the consequences of not serving including the outcome of a mandatory injunction removing an offending extension.
Nutt V Podger (2021) – also looks at the consequences of not serving and SAI Ventures Ltd v Compar Properties Ltd (2016) – delt with the question as to whether additional or new work required a new notice
However, concentrating on the top three:
13 Chaturachinda v Fairholme 2015
This is a case of special foundations , what are they and how has the way we now consider this term changed.
The old London building Acts amendment Act 1939 part VI mentions Special foundations being ‘ foundations in which an assemblage of steel beams or rods is employed for the purpose of distributing any load’ the only difference being the word steel has now been dropped in the new Act. However at the time the 1939 Act was written the assemblage looked more like the drawing on the right of this slide, clearly if this sat across the boundary it would prove difficult if not impossible to remove without serious implications for the building for which it was intended and therefore one can see the need for consent, however, things move on and construction techniques change and whereas before we may have had large assemblages of beams and rods we now employ much simpler measures. Such as the drawing on the left.
Incidentally if you want to know what a bailey rail looks like this is the actual drawing that was used in the case.
In this case the now retired Judge Bailey set out to consider matter of whether the pad or rail of concrete at the bottom of the underpin was to be considered the foundation, and as it contained no reinforcement and as it was this that distributed the load and as it was in mass concrete the question was did it need consent?
Also to get around the term foundation for the underpin section above the rail the reinforced section was called a downward raising of a wall.
The Act provides for raising a wall and the argument was why can a wall not be raised in a downward direction. The judge agreed
Whether you consider the judge’s ruling as a farce or a crude attempt to avoid the argument or as a real favour to the surveying world is up to you , personally I think he did us all a favour, however, my suggestion is that the purpose of the rail should still be considered, simply placing a concrete footing may not be the proper answer and certainly in most cases if it is built this way it’s more likely to cause issues so it might be worth still looking to engage with the AO’s and seeking a consent to avoid a rail being installed.
14 Russell Gray v James Crowley and
15 Russell Gray v James Crowley the Judge’s ruling
– this is another landmark case for surveyors and is far more recent it deals with the subject of immunity and duty of care but beware it’s a county court decision. In recent years certain central London solicitors have tried to use the Act as a weapon threatening surveyors with suit if they did or didn’t do certain things that the Act required of them, this threat of being sued has put many a surveyor off and indeed I have had certain threats as a third surveyor which ultimately got dropped with threats of suing on a third surveyor decision being one.
Surely, we must be able to make a decision with the right action, if it is felt that the decision is wrong, to simply appeal the award, not sue the surveyor. Any way this case seems to show the way the courts may deal with this, and although a lower court and therefore not a binding decision and that it also simply dealing with a third surveyors’ duty of care not the first two surveyors it does seem to show that the quasi – judicial function of the surveyor is to be recognised. hopefully that will stop this type of behavior, watch this space – I would note however, that some surveyors stepping outside of their jurisdiction should be very careful as I’m not convinced an ultra vires action is free from suit.
16 Amir-Siddique v Kowaliw (2018)
The courts do however sometimes throw out curve balls and this case certainly sets a scene that is probably best described as unusual in terms of the outcome. In this case the BO served a notice, they did so without the benefit of a surveyor, the Ao appointed a surveyor and the BO asked if he could represent them as well. The AO refused to allow their surveyor to be used by the Bo.
There was quite a history here so I would suggest a thorough reading of the case might assist in understanding the judge’s ruling where he decided that the costs of the additional surveyor should be met by the AO not the BO as is the norm because they had unnecessary increased the burden of costs for the BO by not allowing him the option to have the surveyor as agreed. Afterall why would you not want your surveyor acting for the neighbor (the BO) ? The judge made the decision and the AO unusually picked up the tab of the second surveyor.
What is interesting here and not covered in the ruling is that it was the owner who refused to allow his surveyor to act for both parties, I think had it been the surveyor refusing to Act for the BO there could be no such ruling as to costs, afterall we (the surveyors) don’t have to act for someone if we don’t want to and that surely that is a surveyor’s prerogative?
Perhaps in the future it might be worth asking if the Ao is willing to accept that you might act for both and if they say no then suggest that you will refuse the second appointment to avoid the potential of the costs falling to them?
17 Can post-work inspections be included in an award?
This seems to be a current argument between surveyors with some suggesting that a second visit is not required others, like me think it is not only ok but essential.
There are arguments for and against but I would point out that under section 10 (13) the act allows for ‘reasonable inspections’
18 Should the award provide for a final inspection of work (with implications for fees etc.)?
Section 10 (13)
Also now turning to Hansard and I spoke at length to Lord Lytton on this subject where he envisioned that additional inspections were required, certainly in Hansard he mentions
19 Hansard
That is essential if surveyors are to [1] draw up schedules of condition and [2] the adjoining owner’s property is to be fully protected by an assessment of necessary precautionary measures.
I believe he also considered the final or post work inspection to be necessary although I can’t find mention of that in Hansard. What I would say is that if someone comes to sell the property it is now not uncommon for the solicitors dealing with the sale to ask if the awards have been discharged. What implications that may have if there is no final inspection may vary from case to case but may stall or even prevent successful sales.
Can I also suggest that often it is a lay person for whom we are acting and how would they know if there is an issue , certainly if there are no internal cracks they are unlikely to even notice movements in their property and they only have 6 years to find out (According to recent rulings of judges), so surely its prudent for all, concerned to set the awards aside and put everyone’s minds at rest at the end of the work ?
It also puts a date stamp on when works area competed and sets the clock running on the 6 years especially where potential final certificates on contracts are inadequate or non-existent.
If I have time, I want to explore a few questions that came to light in a recent seminar – (if I haven’t had time see below for an additional read)
20 raising chimneys - I’m throwing this into the mix as I don’t mind admitting it, it caught me and another co presenter out at a recent seminar – section 2(2) (a) allows for raising party structures and in this case the structure is clearly the whole chimney breast see diagram, however
21 can we raise this chimney
What about this chimney, the party structure isn’t the flues on the AO’s side it is the wall in-between, in this case what do you do with the AO’s flues if you raise the party wall.
Well, this is where we got unstuck, we both knew it was in the Act but we couldn’t find it – its not in the usual section 2 list of works , but finally we turned the page , it isn’t a right it’s a requirement of section 2 and is found in section 2(3) it serves to remind us that no matter how many times we pick up the Act we need to read it from time to time as well !
22 who should we notify ?
We all know that we need to notify owners. And I’m sure you are aware this includes tenants and sometimes sub tenants who have an interest of over a year, but what of occupiers who have short leases or even no interest ?
I bet very few of you are aware of what section 3 says when it comes to replies. Certainly, if an owner consents, we all know that means we can get on with the work , but section 3 also says
Nothing shall prevent a building owner from exercising with the consent in writing of the adjoining owners and of the adjoining occupiers any right conferred on him by section 2
So, we need consent from occupiers? Well, who would have known !! and who among you looks for that consent as well ? After all they have no right to notice.
23 who should be a third surveyor
And it is because of all this case law, uncertainty of definitions and where a little help might be required that you should pick a good third surveyor, not your mate drown the street but someone informed and capable, do please consider the possible needs of the owners and the job in hand and I see nothing wrong with picking an out of area third surveyor (London based for instance) where the job might be complicated.
The role of the third surveyor isn’t to settle matters in dispute between surveyors especially arguments over trivial amounts of fees it is there to provide guidance on genuine misunderstandings or differences of opinion. Don’t weaponise the third surveyor, use them for the purpose of assisting in the resolution of the dispute and remember it’s a dispute between owners – not surveyors !! don’t drag owners into dispute resolve the disputes !!!
24 RICS guide
If you need to know what you should be doing read this ! new version out soon.
25 any questions ?
Paper written by Michael Cooper BSc (Hons) FRICS FPTS